A “merchandise not received” dispute means the cardholder told their bank they never got what they paid for. On Visa this usually appears as reason code 13.1; other networks have equivalents. The bank has already pulled the money back. Your response is your one chance to get it returned.
Evidence that wins
1. Carrier tracking with a delivery scan
The tracking number alone is weak. What matters is the carrier’s delivered status with date, time and location. For higher-value orders, signature confirmation or a delivery photo is much stronger.
2. The delivery address matches what the customer entered
Show the shipping address from the order next to the address on the carrier record. If the billing address matches too, include that, along with the card’s address verification (AVS) result.
3. What the customer did after delivery
This is where most cases are won. Look for emails or chat messages after the delivery date, a product review, a support question about using the product, a repeat order, or logins to their account. Any of these suggests the item arrived.
4. Your policies, as the customer saw them
Include your shipping and refund policies as they appeared at checkout, and show that the customer agreed to them.
5. For digital goods and services
Show access logs, download records, IP addresses and device data that match previous legitimate activity from the same customer.
How to package the response
- Lead with a one-paragraph summary. The bank analyst reads quickly. State the order, the delivery date and the strongest piece of proof first.
- Label every attachment. “Carrier delivery confirmation, 14 March” beats “Screenshot 3”.
- Answer the reason code, not everything. For a not-received claim, focus on delivery. Unrelated evidence dilutes your case.
- Submit before the deadline. Each processor and network sets a response window. A late response is an automatic loss.
Common mistakes that lose cases
- Sending only a tracking number without the delivered status
- Arguing with the customer’s character instead of showing facts
- Forgetting post-delivery contact, which is often the strongest proof
- Fighting cases you can’t win, such as packages genuinely lost in transit; refunding those is cheaper
When it’s worth fighting
Merchants who contest chargebacks win roughly 44% of them on average, according to Chargebacks911’s 2026 field report. The ones that aren’t answered are lost by default. On Stripe alone, $1.3 billion in 2025 dispute losses were tied to merchants not responding.